I Couldn’t See Crater Lake. Here’s What I Saw Instead.

Wide view of Crater Lake’s deep blue water, with Wizard Island and the jagged crater rim rising behind it, framed by pine trees in the foreground.

“Epic! It feels like the spaceship just dropped us in another galaxy!” my husband exclaimed with awe as we stood facing Crater Lake.

I felt a part of me bristle as I looked out into a mass of gray and white haze.

“WOW, this is just incredible,” he went on, picking up his phone to take a photo.

I could hear strangers nearby doing the same, posing for photos, remarking on the spectacular view. And the bristled part started to grow more bristly.

I’ve done enough parts work over the years to recognize that this growing anger wasn’t me. I knew I had plenty of other parts who were just happy to be standing in the sunshine, a refreshing breeze tickling my skin. But the bristly part was growing louder, drowning out the whispers of the contented ones, and that was my cue to speak up.

“Babe,” I began, “there’s a part of me that’s feeling really angry and irritable right now.”

“Okay, that’s exciting,” my husband, who has done parts work of his own, remarked. “Let’s see what they have to say.”

I laughed to myself, thinking about how I would have reacted in a similar scenario years ago. Ten Joys ago would have likely tried to push down the anger, only for it to seep out as a cool tone, snappy remark, or general irritability. Ten Bens ago would have been left walking around one of the most gorgeous places in the world with a very crabby wife, absolutely confused.

“I hear you talking about this incredible scene in front of us, and I have no idea what we’re looking at. Part of me feels completely left out and so angry that I can’t see what you’re looking at and that you haven’t attempted to describe any of it to me.”

Ben squeezed my hand.

“I’m sorry, babe. I think I often forget how much your vision has deteriorated in the past couple years. There was a time not too long ago when you could make a lot of this out.”

Then he went on to describe the panoramic expanse we were hiking beside, from the silky blue water to the crust of earth that rimmed around it like a wooden bowl.

I felt some of the bristles soften, but others maintained their stance.

“I want to see the bluest lake with my eyes, not just hear about it,” they barked at me.

“I know,” I said to the armored bristles. “This is hard. But let’s keep going. Maybe there’s something here for us. There are still some islands of peripheral vision to the side. Maybe we can catch a glimpse.”

The most armored of the bunch did not stand down.

“Those measly islands of vision? They’re worthless when it comes to anything really important, like seeing color or reading or seeing anything in detail. Sure, they help avoid obstacles, but they’re not what we need now. We need the pinhole back!”

I knew the pinhole they spoke of. That little pinhole of central vision I had relied on for so many years.

I remember my childhood ophthalmologist, Dr. Fishman, once remarking that the little pinhole of central vision in my right eye was my whole world. And he wasn’t wrong.

I learned to use it so well that I could read novels, read aloud to my students when I was in the classroom, glimpse the beautiful faces of my daughters, their blue eyes framed in curls.

That pinhole wasn’t much, but it was enough.

For some reason, I thought it would remain for a very long time. I remember telling my mother-in-law in 2021 that I wanted to see Italy before I lost my vision. In my mind, that was still years away. When our family planned a trip there in 2024, we eventually backed out, partly because of finances. But there was another reason I didn’t say aloud. I knew we’d be surrounded by people oohing and aahing over stained glass and the Italian countryside, and I knew I could no longer experience those things the way I once had.

The RP had entered the pinhole.

A friend who also has late-stage RP once described it as a piece of wax paper being placed over her central vision. I find the description fitting. There is no color or clarity through this wax paper, and it seems to thicken each year.

At a recent vision appointment, the doctor mapped the remaining islands of vision around my periphery. There are quite a few, and they help with mobility. Still, sometimes I wish I could have directed the RP myself. Cover those islands with wax paper instead. Leave my pinhole alone.

Why did it have to take my little sliver, the one holding my world together?

But I guess RP, like life, doesn’t give those kinds of choices.

“Let’s keep walking,” I told Ben. “Maybe I’ll catch a glimpse from the side as I turn my head.”

“Totally,” he said. “And maybe you’ll be able to perceive some of it with your other senses. There’s a certain energy to places like this. You can kind of feel the open expanse.”

He guided my hand toward a rock, and I ran my fingers across its rough surface.

The bristles were unimpressed.

“This is just a stupid rock. You’re missing out on the panoramic enormity of all of this.”

I understood their point. We talk a lot in the disability community about the social model of disability, the idea that many of the things that disable us are barriers society has constructed. But standing at Crater Lake, part of me wanted to argue with the model. Nobody designed this lake to be inaccessible. Sometimes nature itself seems to ask us to see.

And I couldn’t.

So we kept walking.

At one point, as we paused to take another selfie, I turned my head and caught something through one of those islands of peripheral vision.

A sliver.

Joy standing with a sparkly, bedazzled white cane before Crater Lake’s deep blue water, wearing sunglasses and a green hoodie, hands clasped over her cane.

I’m not sure I can even tell you exactly what I saw. I don’t know if it was the lake itself, or a piece of the rim, or simply light and shape coming together for an instant. Maybe my brain filled in something my eyes couldn’t quite perceive. Maybe I was sensing the enormity Ben had described, that strange energy of an open expanse.

Whatever it was, for a moment, I glimpsed Crater Lake.

Not the blue Ben spoke of.

Not the entire picture.

But something.

And I felt the armored bristles begin to bow ever so slightly.

Nothing had changed. I still couldn’t see the lake the way I wanted to. The pinhole was still gone. The rock was still, frankly, just a rock.

But the bristles had been heard.

And that seemed to make enough room for some of the other parts, the joyful ones, the grateful ones who had been silently standing by, to rise to the surface.

I felt the shadow of a smile grace my face as the cane my daughter had bedazzled for me grazed the path ahead.

A couple of tourists passed by, and I faintly heard a man remark, “That puts things in perspective, huh?”

I can’t be certain he was referring to me.

I got that all-too-familiar feeling I have when I’m in a very visual place and imagine what passersby may be thinking.

I don’t want people to pity me.

I don’t want to pity myself.

But sometimes they do.

And sometimes I do.

As we continued walking, I turned my head from time to time, searching those little islands at the edges.

Every so often, something appeared.

A glimpse.

Maybe light. Maybe shape. Maybe Crater Lake. Maybe simply a sense of the place.

Lately, the loss of my pinhole has felt painfully recent, still close enough that part of me keeps reaching for what used to be there. And yet here I was, receiving the world in another way, in fragments and flashes I couldn’t force or fully explain.

Maybe glimpses are a little like a creative muse. You can make space for them. You can pay attention. You can turn toward them. But you can’t demand that they arrive.

Sometimes they show up.

On a hike.

On a drive.

In a crater.

And sometimes they don’t.

In this lifetime, we do not get to choose the slivers of joy that show up. We only get to choose whether to receive them.

Maybe we don’t always need to know exactly what we’re seeing.

Maybe, when a glimpse comes, we just turn our heads toward it.

And let the bristles bow.

Ben and Joy smile for a selfie at Crater Lake, Ben with a full beard and glasses in a red hoodie, Joy beside him in sunglasses and a green hoodie, the blue lake and rim behind them.

Good Grief / Dear RP

When you experience a loss in life, you experience grief.  We usually think of grieving as a process we go through after someone close to us dies, but I think we often forget that we also need to grieve other losses in life– divorce, major illness of a family member, moving far away from friends/family, and of course the loss of certain abilities.  I will always remember a woman in one of my Psych. classes in college talking about her son who lost four of his fingers in a machinery accident (not vision-related).  She got very choked up while talking about her son and how he was going through grief counseling to deal with the psychological impact of losing his fingers– literally pieces of himself that he could never get back.  I remember thinking it was strange how the human mind can be so attached to the body– to the point that it suffers when the body suffers.I know I’ve mentioned my counselor in a couple previous posts and have walked through the process of uncovering the truth about past negative experiences before (see “Flying Balls Part 2:  Totally Pucked”).  And while I am not trying to “play psychologist” here, I do want to share one other homework assignment that my therapist gave me that I think is helpful for anyone grieving a loss.She told me to write a letter about all of the things I hate about Retinitis Pigmentosa.  I have to admit that I was kind of irritated with this assignment at first, thinking that it would just be re-hashing all of my negative thoughts about RP, and I remember thinking “yeah lady, that’s why I’m here– to GET RID of all these thoughts and just accept it for what it is– not wallow in it!”  She then had me read the letter aloud, which was definitely difficult for me.

I completed this assignment after only a couple sessions, so it has been several months now since I have read this letter.  I find it amazing how I can read portions of this letter now without feeling the intense emotion that I once felt.  Many of the phrases, such as those depicting shame and humiliation, even sound kind of ridiculous to me now, which makes me feel proud of how much progress toward acceptance I have made.

Sometimes we have to face intense discomfort– even pain– in order to move forward.  I think I was stuck in the same RP rut for quite some time, and it has taken a combination of counseling, blogging, and talking with other RPers to start feeling good again.

I am including the letter I wrote below.  Like the hockey puck story, I feel pretty vulnerable throwing this out into the internet oblivion, wondering whether people I know will be reading my intimate thoughts, but I think it will be helpful for those with RP to show an example of just “letting it all out” for the sake of the assignment.

(note:  If you try this at home for purposes not involving RP, probably don’t write the hate letter directly to a person and mail it….Just sayin’)

Dear RP,

There are so many things I hate about you.

I hate running into the dishwasher. I hate running into objects that are completely obvious to others.  I hate having consantly-bruised shins.  I hate the pain you cause me.

I hate bumping into people (literally– not in the friendly sense)  I hate tripping over small children.  I hate missing an outstretched hand when being introduced to someone.  I hate the look on the cashier’s face when I haven’t seen a receipt as it is being handed to me.  I hate being asked if I am intoxicated when I am completely sober..  I hate when people know something is wrong with me.  I hate walking slowly in front of others because I am afraid I will fall down a flight of stairs.  I hate when I appear rude when I fail to wave to someone.  I hate the embarrassment of circling around a store, looking for my shopping cart, when it is right in front of me.   I hate the humiliation you cause me.

I hate all of the emotional pain I went through in school– mean, jerky kids who called me “spacey”, being hit in the nose with a hockey puck and in the face with a volleyball in PE class, being one of the last kids picked for teams and making our team lose games.  I hate that I had to be pulled out of class by a “vision itinerant” who knew nothing about me and did nothing to help me.  I hate that I had to grow up with you.

I hate not driving.  I hate having to plan rides for every little activity that my kids and I want to do.  I hate that every little change in plans, such as my husband’s work schedule changing, leads to more complicated plans.  I hate dealing with plans that should be very simple but end up being ridiculously difficult.  I hate missing events and time with friends/family because I have no way to get there.  I hate getting stuck places.  I hate waiting.  I hate having to ask for constant favors from people.  I hate not being able to take my 5-year-old out to breakfast or shopping just by ourselves.  I hate not being able to just get in a car BY MYSELF and go ANYWHERE. I hate that I can’t make a mistake, like forgetting something at home, without it affecting people besides myself.  I hate feeling like I am an “eternal pre-teen”, getting dropped off and picked up places at others’ convenience.  I hate the independence you’ve taken from me.

I hate having to fumble for my magnifying glass when I can’t read the stupid small print on the directions for my baby’s medication or the instructions on a game or the recipe on a box of risotto.  I hate not being able to read the menu in many restaurants.  I hate not being able to even find my way to the table in dim-lit restaurants.  I hate that I can’t even leave a movie to go to the bathroom alone for fear that I won’t find my seat when I return.  I hate not being able to go running at night.  I hate being nervous even on a bicycle.  I hate that my -5-year-old has to lead me into the dark locker room at the water park.  I hate not being able to read– or sometimes even find– expiration dates.  I hate not being able to read a lot of ingredients in items at the store.  I hate the daily inconviences you cause me.

I hate appearing sighted one minute and blind the next.  I hate the idea that I could sometimes walk better if I used a cane.  I hate having to tell people about my vision, or lack of it.  I hate the confusion of not knowing when to ask for help.  I hate the shame you cause me.

I hate disappointing my children.  I hate it when my 5-year-old wants to go to the library with me but is told no because we can’t get there.  I hate that I’ve messed up drawings or paintings of her’s when she has asked me to help her.  I hate that I can’t figure out how to put certain toys or puzzles together because I can’t read the instructions or figure them out visually.  I hate that I mistakenly run into my 1-year-old almost daily and feel guilty each time I knock her over.  I hate that I don’t see stains on my kids’ clothing and sometimes don’t notice food on their faces.  I hate not being a “normal” mom.  I hate that you’ve taken certain things away, not just from me, but from my children.

I hate not knowing how much sight I will have in the future. I hate wondering if my fields have gotten smaller or the print has shrunk.  I hate worrying whether I will be able to see my kids grow up or view the faces of my grandkids someday.  I hate worrying that the computer will have a negative effect on my vision as I order groceries online.  I hate wondering if I should be searching for a career that doesn’t rely as much on sight as teaching does.  I hate the uncertainty you cause me.

Really, I could probably ramble on even longer about all the things I hate about you.  I’m not sure it’s doing much good, though– maybe slightly therapeutic (well, I would hope so, since this started out as an assignment from my therapist!)  But now what?  How do I move past all this HATE?

Sure, I can think of a few areas in which RP has made me stronger– compassion, sensitivity to others,  detail-oriented planning, and humility.  But it just seems like these all came at quite a cost.